Court rules in favor of male student in sexual-assault case | KOB 4
Advertisement

Court rules in favor of male student in sexual-assault case

By DAN SEWELL
February 09, 2018 02:21 PM

CINCINNATI (AP) — A federal appeals court ruled Friday in favor of a male student who blames gender discrimination for an Ohio college's finding that he violated its sexual-assault policy.

Advertisement

A three-judge 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel upheld a lower court's dismissal of several claims against Miami University and school officials, but found that the student presented enough factual allegations to support a "reasonable inference" of discrimination.

The student, identified in court documents as "John Doe," said most of Miami's sexual misconduct cases are against males who are then ruled responsible without fair hearings. He was suspended for a 2014 encounter with a female acquaintance who said he went ahead with sexual acts when she told him not to after they had some consensual activity.

The student said he was too drunk to remember anything that happened after she got into his bed.

Miami and other U.S. universities have been accused in other cases in recent years of violating male students' rights as the schools step up efforts against campus sexual assaults amid pressure by federal education authorities.

Pre-trial evidence "may reveal that the alleged patterns of gender-based decision-making do not, in fact, exist," Judge Karen Nelson Moore wrote, but added that the Miami student "has sufficiently pleaded circumstantial evidence of gender discrimination."

"We're extremely excited to see that the 6th Circuit has accepted our gender bias arguments and look forward to prosecuting our case," said his attorney, Eric Rosenberg.

The university didn't have an immediate comment when asked about the decision.

The original lawsuit asked for unspecified damages and legal costs and his university records of the case to be expunged.

The appeals court rejected other legal claims, including one that the school was "deliberately indifferent" to sexual misconduct by the female student because she kissed him when he was too inebriated to consent.

___

Follow Dan Sewell at http://www.twitter.com/dansewell

Credits

By DAN SEWELL

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.

Advertisement



Advertisement

Relay Media Amp

Advertisement


Advertisement




Police: Student confessed to making threat, claimed it was a hoax

Investigation into ART underway, city says

Winter weather hits New Mexico

City announces youth summer jobs

Santa Fe County deputies investigate two suspicious deaths